jupiter, the bringer of jollity analysis

jupiter, the bringer of jollity analysis

Jupiter adds majesty, benevolence and triumphant zeal to the concoction, with its many themes adding a true sense of adventure. Its an amalgamation of the harps, glockenspiel and celeste playing oscillating chords throughout the movement, which give it the hypnotic and mystical sound. Any meaningful consideration of Planets recordings begins here. This creates a percussive sound, which is very exciting and keeps with the theme of this movement representing war. Billed annually at $39.99 Edit Release New Submission. Venus, the Bringer of Peace To Leo, Venus represents affection, devotion, an even disposition, a refined nature and a keen appreciation of art and beauty, in contrast to Holst's subtitle which suggests simplification to a single attribute. Mullenger further hears the climactic syncopated gasps as recalling Holst's asthma and his struggling for breath as a child. He died on 25 May 1934 in Ealing, Middlesex, London, England, UK. The full orchestra winds up "in a bubbling cauldron of sound" (Crankshaw) only to vanish with a massive pained tutti chord as "a sudden deflated collapse into a dismal heap of nothingness" (James). In theory the pipe organ can overcome much of this problem with its panoply of distinctive voices, awesome power and ability to preserve a sustained mood (especially in the atmospheric Neptune), but a version by Peter Sykes (on a 1996 Raven CD) all too often comes across as a homogeneous sonic blur compared to the original. These bursts also give an insight into the military feel as you can often hear fanfares from the brass section. Jupiter, the Bringer of Jollity 5. A stronger influence perhaps was that of Stravinsky, whose music had greatly impressed Holst before he took on the universe, the effects of which in The Planets can be seen in the very large Firebird and Petrushka kind of orchestration, in insistent rhythms, and also in striding rhythmic shifts. The frantic scramble at the end of the movement leads up to the massive stabs at the end, which bring the whole orchestra together to create an exciting and powerful end to this movement. This masterpiece was originally scored for an unusually large orchestra - with several relatively obscure instruments. Louis (Turnabout, 1975), Solti/London (Decca, 1979), Maazel/France (CBS, 1980), Dutoit/Montreal (1986, Decca) and Gardiner/Philharmonia (DG, 1994). : Westminster Abbey I Vow to Thee My Country +2 - They played it during Princess Diana's funeral (it's her favorite hymn) and the camera zoom out from . (When he became interested in Hindu literature through translations, he proceeded to learn the original Sanskrit and wrote several Hindu-inspired works including two operas, Sita and Savitri.) 6. Sure enough, six years later The Tomita Planets (RCA LP) became a pop culture phenomenon, albeit a short-lived one, as Imogen Holst charged that it mutilated the copyrighted original and successfully sued to enjoin further sales. Buy song $0.99. Apparently it was successful, as they returned in August 1923 for Venus, Uranus and Mercury (plus the "Marching Song" from Holst's Songs Without Words as a backing for Mercury, which fit on a single side) and completed the cycle with Mars in October, Neptune in November and Saturn in February 1924. Perhaps not, but it does however encapsulate the tormenting and thunderous feelings of war and the devastating consequences. The album of four 78s was issued in automatic sequence (with a 1937 Boult/BBC Symphony Elgar "Imperial March" as the eighth side following the second half of Jupiter, rather than backing Mercury) and thus, unlike with the individual discs of the Holst and Coates sets, effectively prescribed that the movements were to be heard in order, wrapping up with the triumphant conclusion of Jupiter, even though Imogen reports that Holst particularly disliked such a false "happy ending.". Often analogized to a symphonic scherzo, it's light, agile, playful and fully reflects an active mind eagerly searching for meaning amid disparate sources. The end of the movement is essentially a recap of earlier themes and bringing them together for the climatic end. funfetti pancake mix cookies jupiter, the bringer of jollity analysis. It seems the approach with this movement is not how much you do, its actually what you dont do as a result of this. C Theme. Yet unlike, say, Mussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition or Ravel's Tombeau de Couperin that were conceived for the keyboard and only later adapted for orchestra, Holst wrote the piano version of The Planets largely out of necessity and with the full intention of orchestrating it (and apparently with no thought of public performance, as it was only published posthumously). (Ian Lane) As with English madrigals and folk songs, Holst was fascinated by the use in Eastern music of non-Western scales, spare textures and unconventional time signatures of 5, 7 and even 21 beats (which he declared were more suitable for setting English words) and incorporated those features into two operas and dozens of settings of Indian religious texts. The middle section presents a surprising contrast -- a majestic flowing melody in 3/4 . Release [r26171738] Copy Release Code. That said, he and his orchestra produced quite a credible performance. As compiled by Greene, once the entire work was heard, many critics condemned reductions to mere excerpts and were generally ecstatic in praising the immediacy, eloquence, clarity of expression, originality and importance of the entire work (although he further attributes the devotion of English critics to a reflection of national pride, whereas others' views were more tempered, with some dwelling on its derivative nature and one dismissing it as "an anthology of musical platitudes. In art, Jupiter was often depicted as a bearded man with a thunderbolt in his hand. Holst's musico-spatial explorations may not be cosmic, but they are brilliant, dramatic, and picturesque enough to fit into almost anyone's concert hall horoscope. VIDEO COMMENT Holst's "Jupiter" +9 - As long as it's played well it sounds amazing on anything: : Gustav Holst - A Fugal Overture (1922) +3 - Holst didn't write a movement for Earth, but the Fugal Overture would be an interesting insertion . Jupiter Gustav Holst's Planets don't exactly line up like the real ones he skips Earth and Pluto, which wouldn't be discovered until a dozen years after The Planets premiered. Indeed, robbed of its usual quirky edge, his Mars is suffused with a world-weary air and casts a pall over the rest of the work that is never fully dispelled; its final chords seem weighed down with regret, aptly leading into a Venus that seems less an aura of peace than a futile plea. Flaws aside, Holst is an enormously persuasive advocate for his Planets and either set affords the incomparable thrill of eavesdropping on a composer supplementing the cold written score to infuse his creation with the essence of his personal creative spirit. Karajan's was the only other Planets (aside from Boult and Sargent remakes) to emerge during the entire decade of the 'sixties. Boult calls it "a perfect impression of winged lightness" and its harmonic ambivalence "a wonderful sense of elusiveness as of quicksilver.". 32 between 1914-1916. The swelling brass and slow waltzing strings are met with moments of poignant beauty in the glorious tune now known as I Vow to Thee My Country. Along with this rhythmic ambiguity, there is no set key to the piece, you can make a guess of where the tonality may be, but it is quite tricky. Download and print in PDF or MIDI free sheet music for Jupiter, The Bringer Of Jollity by Gustav Holst arranged by justice24798 for Euphonium, Clarinet in b-flat, Trumpet in b-flat (Mixed Trio) Jupiter, the Bringer of Jollity by Patrick Gleeson, Joybringer by Manfred Mann's Earth Band, Call Any Vegetable [Edited- Hybrid Concert] by Frank Zappa & Cruisin' For Burgers [ZINY 40th. The Planets is best known for his orchestral composition. The ladies choir bring a human quality to the movement, again it seems Holst is trying to connect with us with the use of the human voice. Subscribe to Plus. Again, the contrast of moods and texture within the movement really do highlight how wonderful a composer and orchestrator Holst really is. And since the British composer was distressed at the immediate success of the seven-movement work when it was introduced in 1919 - he never considered it one of his best efforts - its rebirth could only cause him further chagrin. This adaptation condenses this monumental movement into a 5-part + percussion arrangement. Answer (1 of 3): Another Quorean has already provided a very comprehensive list, including all the ones that I could think of but one film composer in particular comes to mind who has made more use of Holst's work than most: Not only 'Jupiter', but the influence of the whole of 'The Planet Suite'. From the Album Gustav Holst: The Planets . Rhythm to Holst was the most important thing in life, and in this recording he never for one moment allows the rhythm to sag, with the result that Mars sounds even more relentless than usual." Jupiter is the largest and oldest planet in the solar system, born about 4.5 billion years ago. So after. The theme is undoubtedly celebratory, taking us on a whirlwind of emotions which is full of climatic passion, zeal and triumphant feelings. This quirky theme is soon left behind as the second theme enters, which is a basic fanfare theme that is varied throughout this shorter section. This movement in general is quite unconventional, which has been said to represent the idea that Uranus as a planet moves on its own side axis, which in itself is different. Underneath this, the double basses play a slow and expansive theme which grows into fruition slightly later in the movement. Soon to enter are the horns, lower strings and both sets of timpani with a syncopated theme which builds into the fabric of this first theme (of a mighty six for this movement!). Download 'Symphony No.6 in D major (2)' on iTunes, This image appears in the gallery:A beginners guide to Gustav Holsts The Planets Suite. Mars, the Bringer of War Holst wastes no time launching his Planets with startling gestures. Even within each movement, Holst does not organically develop his themes symphonically, but rather uses them to create a structure suited to the psychological character and associations of each planet. As several commentators have pointed out, while some of the mythological references seem appropriate (Mars, Holst's "Bringer of War," indeed was the Roman god of war), others seem obscure (Neptune, Holst's "Mystic," was merely the sea god). All Rights Reserved. Unlike Stravinsky, who recorded his seminal ballets only once his style had evolved radically from expressionist firebrand to detached neoclassicist, Holst began committing his Planets to disc a few years after its premiere, with the creative impulse presumably still fresh in his mind. They play a fifth interval, then drop a semitone, which is repeated throughout this section. After the calmness of Venus, we bounce straight into the third movement, Mercury The Winged Messenger, which takes us on an exciting journey, though it is only brief, with this movement being the shortest of the seven. Such associations aside, in purely musical terms the movement begins in a soft piano menace, builds to a terrifying triple forte (fff) climax as instruments pile on, is halted by a massive discord followed by a slower 5/2 section still "haunted by the martial rhythm" after which the opening "returns with increased, almost hysterical, ferocity, ending with grinding chords" (Kennedy) as strings, brass and tympani dissonantly pound out the initial figure quadruple forte (ffff) as its rhythm finally disintegrates. After the relative handful of recordings during the first half-century of its existence, and nearly a decade after Karajan became the last outsider to break the British hegemony of artists, the marketing floodgates opened in the early 1970s with a sudden abundance of a half-dozen new Planets LPs, to be joined since then by dozens more. I do believe that this movement provides a representation for the prime of life, making it at the centre of musical expression and impressive melodies which create a feel-good wave of sound for the listener. As Holst has not used lots of different themes, more he has stretched and varied a small selection, the excitement from this piece comes from short bursts of sound, which are usually initiated by the brass. A callous texture is imposed by having the strings play the ostinato col legno (using the wooden back of the bow rather than the hair hardly a favorite technique of artists cherishing their precious instruments), with the harps providing a cavernous edge by playing along in their lowest register. In notes to his 1967 recording, Boult expressed the hope that his BBC set "came near the composer's intentions" and that his subsequent recordings, while taking advantage of technical improvements, would "still sound faithful and authentic." "), Perhaps in keeping with his visionary outlook and disdain for fame, unlike nearly all other composers Holst thwarted popular expectation by resisting the temptation to follow The Planets with a successor of a similar structure or style. Burnett James adds that while traditional astrology attempts to predict individual destiny from one's time and place of birth, Holst was more intrigued by the associative emotional connotations of each planet and in particular the psychological attributes that Leo ascribed to each planet (although Leo later would come to consider the sun to be dominant). As Schoenberg put it in his own anarchistic program note: "The music seeks to express all that swells in us subconsciously like a dream; which is a great fluctuant power, and is built upon none of the lines that are familiar to us; which has a rhythm, as blood has a pulsating rhythm, as all life in us has its rhythm; which has a tonality, but only as the sea or the storm has its tonality; which has harmonies, though we cannot grasp or analyze them nor can we trace its themes." Cl. So what makes the twinkling sound within this movement? If so, then the rest of The Planets, both psychologically and musically, can be heard as proposing various paths to redemption or, perhaps collectively, a fervent prayer that mankind would find some way to carry on by embracing our better sides. Ob. The Planets Op.32 : VII Neptune, the Mystic. The simple answer is that Pluto was only discovered and named in 1930, long after The Planets took final form. But perhaps one of the earliest foretastes of that bond came with the 1970 reissue of the 1960 Boult/Vienna State Opera Orchestra Planets on Westminster Gold, a label known for metaphoric and often witty (if occasionally tasteless) covers that presumably strove to lure unwitting pop fans to the classics. The most widely-mentioned influence, hardly surprising from the very titles of the individual movements, is astrology. RT @opRaystorm: jupiter, the bringer of jollityVO4 # #VO4 #. Jupiter, Bringer of Jollity" is the central movement of Gustav Holst's Planets Suite and has the most varied melodic structure: with its Stravinsky-like ostinati and syncopation and a central melody as solemn as an anthem, it constitutes the quintessential early-20th-century English composition. This is heightened by the harp and celeste parts, which push arpeggios and oscillating chords throughout. He was also known as the bringer of jollity, which meant he was responsible for good times and good luck. 32, is a seven-movement orchestral suite by the English composer Gustav Holst, written between 1914 and 1917.In the last movement the orchestra is joined by a wordless female chorus. The adjective jovial originally described those born under the planet of Jupiter, reputed to be jolly, optimistic, and buoyant . The exuberance of this movement shows itself not only in its tempo and rhythm but also in the multiplicity of subjects. Its small details like the bass flute bringing a darker timbre underneath the concert flutes, and the celeste bringing a beautiful dulcet tone alongside the harp. 7 images Jupiter is named after the Roman king of the gods. Silencing the organ, percussion, trumpets, trombones and tuba, Holst 's texture "concentrates on delicate and lucid tone colors" of woodwinds, harps, celesta and solo violin (Halbreich), creating "an essay in benignity" in which "our feet have been placed in some posture of security" (Crankshaw), "bringing to the suffering world a vision of heavenly peace" as Venus "sails softly across the evening sky, bringing with her a still, starlit repose" (James) and "the skies are soothed by a gentle benediction" (Freed). With deep roots, both parental and musical, in England and Russia, Coates absorbed the unabashed subjective outlook of his mentor Arthur Nikisch, who reportedly told him to trade his conductor's baton for a whip. 'Jupiter, the Bringer of Jollity' is the exuberant (and very English) central movement of Holst's 'The Planets' suite, arranged here for wind quintet. This is a concept we can all relate to and the idea of growing old is seen differently by everybody, therefore when the solemnn procession enters it affects people in different ways as people will see it subjectively. For details on how we use cookies, see our. In keeping with Leo's guidance, Malcolm Sargent, a close associate, recalled that Holst didn't believe in astrology as being prophetic, but rather was attracted by the notion of each planet shedding rays of influence upon the earth and mankind. He has come down from Olympus to flirt with beauties in the mortal . Upon seeing the score there are some areas where there are two chords appearing simultaneously, yet they have no diatonic relationship whatsoever. We feel that a vast journey has transpired and even more significantly that a wider exploration awaits us" (Crankshaw). The reason is unclear upon reflection did Holst feel a need to correct the original pacings, or perhaps were his own views capricious (and thus should not be taken by others as definitive)? $34.99 Merry-go-round Of Life $24.99 Advanced Orchestral Studies $50.00 Symphony No. After a brief backward glance and a massive organ pedal point, a few fragments of the spirited theme linger as "faint stars in a silent void to prepare us for the final vision" (Freed). Thus the world was hardly prepared for the innovative and eclectic Planets, which seemingly arose from a near-void and, much to the composer's frustration, despite his variegated output came to define him as a "one-hit wonder.". Mars is the first movement of the suite, and it is known for its power and strength. Holst's work comprises seven movements, each devoted to a particular planet in our solar system (excluding the earth, the focus of the other planets' influences), beginning with the inner three but in reverse order from their distance from the sun, and then proceeding outwards through the rest. Look at the detail: the Great Red Spot . Or even it could musically represent the breakout of WW1 (as Holst was writing this movement in 1915). $9.00 $3.95 $3.75 Studio Ghibli Suite $120.00 Ukrainian National Anthem for Symph. And let me also say that, out of an abundance of fairness and as a service to my dear readers, I did try to emulate its presumed target audience by listening again to the Tomita Planets while stoned but the effect seemed just as meaningless and pretentious and way too long.). Smooth Classics with Myleene Klass ]: biography and "The Planets" information on the. The movement paints a wonderful landscape of sound which, even with the lack of musical transitions, is still musically exciting. The overall tone is militaristic in sharp, percussive, insistent ostinato 5/4 time. This magnificent work by Gustav Holst is scored in a very /item/detail/I/Jupiter - Bringer of Jollity/2155315 The fidelity (possibly goosed in digital transfers) is markedly improved over the predecessors', displays a greater realm of textures, especially in the delicate instrumental interplay of Venus, and allows finer appreciation of the magnitude of Holst's flair for colorful orchestration. Although Macmillan was a multi-talented composer, author and teacher who was cherished as Canada's foremost musician, he and the Toronto orchestra he raised to prominence and led for 25 years were barely known abroad and it is unclear why they cut the next Planets and why only the first four movements. Sargent's reading is remarkably potent, from a downright spooky opening as Mars seethes toward a giant climax, to alarmingly loud bells that shake off any sense of torpor in Saturn, and earth-shaking organ pedal points and huge tympani that magnify the drama of Uranus. The concept of the work is based not on the Roman deities that they may relate to, but the influence of the planets on the psyche, which consequently makes this work astrological, not astronomical (hence why Earth is not included). In short, this movement reveals Holst as the gutsy risk-taker that he was. Jupiter - The Bringer of Jollity The fourth movement of the suite, Jupiter is perhaps the most famous of them all, especially the main theme that is heard in the middle of the movement. These pieces were each a representation of how each planet's characteristics is depicted. Burnett James paints Holst as a lonely and tragic figure, assailed with agonizing spiritual blight and a bleak despair that enveloped his whole being (and which ultimately led him to increasingly dissociate his later music from emotion). Holst's own imagination had been stimulated by many things, not the least of which was the great literature of English folk songs, introduced to him by his life-long friend, Ralph Vaughan Williams. You can count four, five or six of them, depending on whether you divide the first two into their component parts - they do behave like independent themes. While lacking the patience or interest to attempt to hear them all (for that, please refer to the Peter's Planets site), two struck me of particular promise: Of the rest of the crop of Planets recordings, at least among those I've heard, I've especially enjoyed Steinberg/Boston (DG, 1970), Bernstein/New York (Columbia, 1970), Previn/London (EMI, 1973), Susskind/St. 8. Perhaps for that reason Holst wrote it last, rather than in order as with all the other movements, so that it could subsume the qualities of his other planets. Greene adds that Holst regarded planetary influence as a metaphor for various aspects of human personality and through each movement of The Planets sought to portray psychological drama within aspects of human character. Even so, the balance favors the strings to the detriment of the other choirs, such that the rapid accompanying violin figurations swamp the majestic brass introduction of the rousing Jupiter melody, and the tympani are barely heard at all. Release date from LSO Discography . I generally disparage those who routinely dismiss acoustical recordings as primitive and unworthy of attention (and thus ignore a crucial slice of our cultural heritage), but in this instance the electrical remake, coming soon after and fundamentally similar in approach, strikes me as superior, not only in terms of sonic fidelity and overcoming most of the compromises required by the tyranny of the earlier mechanism but in the quality of the execution and Holst's more assured leadership (even though, while lacking the skills and experience of a trained conductor, by 1922 he had led The Planets in public many times). Isao Tomita was a Japanese pioneer who sought to move electronic music beyond imitations of conventional instruments by applying a full range of sound that he envisioned as comparable to a painter's palette. A more distant inspiration came from Holst's fascination with Hindu philosophy and Sanskrit literature. 10pm - 1am, Symphony No.6 in D major (2) What the title doesn't suggest, though, is that I was [i]not[/i] doing okay this month. This bombastic, heavy march theme is heard a fair bit throughout this movement and is often interrupted by the first four-note fanfare theme. It is made mainly of hydrogen with a quarter helium and has at least 69 moons. Boult also led the first public performance on February 27, 1919, while Holst still was away, but omitted the final two serene movements (perhaps in part to save the cost of the wordless female chorus that makes its only appearance at the end of Neptune). Rare enough in Western music, Holst's rhythm is neither the smooth "loping waltz" of the Tchaikovsky "Pathetique Symphony" nor the teasing bounce of Paul Desmond's "Take Five" nor even the urgent thrust of Ginger Baker's "Do What You Like." The fourth movement of the suite has the title Jupiter, the Bringer of Jollity" and was written in 1914. In doing so, he opened an entirely new world for himself." The headnotes below list the conductor and the orchestra in bold (the choir's role is too brief to warrant mention), followed in parentheses by the year, original label and format and, if different, the reissue I heard. Its focus of attention on astrology can almost certainly be credited with the renewal of interest in his orchestral suite, The Planets. Even though he composed other pieces such as Sita, an opera, Beni Mora, and Cloud Messenger, nothing elevated him to the level of artistic greatness as The Planets did. General Analysis and Outline of Jupiter JUPITER, the bringer of jollity. $9.00 . David Trippett observes that The Planets's popularity soared as conductors vied with each other to present local premieres; one such dispute was settled when orchestras in Chicago and New York agreed to introduce The Planets to North America on the same night. Several commentators trace specific movements of The Planets to emulations of the atmosphere and orchestration in sections of Schoenberg's Pieces. A stately, more serious processional theme then enters, its royal dignity fully intact, after which the vigorous melody returns. Guardian Headline src url https assets.guim.co.uk static frontend fonts guardian headline noalts not hinted GHGuardianHeadline Light.woff2 http3 true format woff2 url https assets.guim.co.uk static frontend fonts guardian headline latin1 not hinted GHGuardianHeadline Light.woff http3 true format woff. While critics at the time seemed divided along a predictable generational divide, one enthused that: "Holst might have really dug it." Reviews. I must emphasize that this does not purport to be a comprehensive or definitive survey, as I've only focused on the pioneering recordings that strike me as having significant historical and stylistic interest. Gustav Mahler Symphony No.2: Movement III, Gustav Mahler Symphony No.2: Movement II, Gustav Mahler: Symphony No.2 Genesis & Movement I, Ralph Vaughan Williams English Folk Song Suite: Memorable Melodies, Alexander von Zemlinksy Symphony No. jupiter, the bringer of jollity analysis. - No. In a somewhat related development of pop culture, not only Williams's Star Wars but countless other sci-fi outer-space movie soundtracks have been (and still are being) derived from The Planets. He gave as an example: "Mercury is the symbol of mind." Dvorak's 5th Symphony ("New World,". As Foreman notes, the resulting torso left an impression of undue heaviness. His Planets belies his reputation for levelheaded performances of precision and polish that is, being more dependable than exhilarating and in the process further dispels notions of Holst's own artistic temperament as methodical and cautious. Rather, it projects a sense of jagged complication, driven forward by a beat of eighth notes yet stumbled by another beat of triplets, a rhythm that is challenging to follow and that defeats with faltering indecision any notion of regularity or feeling of stability. 10,000+ blues, R&B, rock, jazz and pop 78s, 45s, LPs and CDs and even some ragas, punk and rap. So for instance he uses contrary motion scales between the upper winds and the tuned percussion to create a different kind of scalic sound. rapzh.com 2017 - 2023. There are points where the time signature is less obvious and that is part of the whole excitement of the movement! Holst writes this movement in 5/4 time, which gives the feeling of uncomfortable movement at times. With these new lines of interest, Holst started to learn how each planet bears a different characteristic in terms of astrology, and what this means within the bigger picture. After Holst heard it at a January 1914 London concert (at which it was largely despised by both audience and critics) he bought the score, heavily annotated it, and regarded it as one of his most valued possessions. Vernon Leidig Full Orchestra Conductor Score Grade: 3 Item: 00-12202S. In particular, he cautioned with respect to Mars: "I well remember the composer's insistence on the stupidity of war as well as all its other horrors, and I feel that the movement can easily be played so fast that it becomes too restless and energetic and loses some of its relentless, brutal and stupid power." The Planets. The third theme is marked pesante which means heavy or peasant like. To keep our ears interested, Holst dashes quickly between tonalities, and never quite settles down into one key. Unfortunately, only Mars, Mercury, Jupiter and Uranus were recorded, perhaps to focus on the faster movements that were easiest to capture, would have the most popular appeal, would provide a marketing advantage by fitting onto four rather than seven discs, and seemed best matched to Coates's spontaneous musical temperament. The main and hymn-like themes of Jupiter Holst bounces through keys creates a fresh and exciting sound, which contrasts again to the previous movement. Rapidly ascending scalar motion. In the interim between Pluto's ascent and demise it must have seemed tempting to complete the task that Holst, by necessity, had left unfinished, while dissuaded from the heresy of tampering with the magical ending of Neptune.

How To Remove Smell From Dosa Batter, Peaster Vs Shallowater Basketball, Walter Auto Sales Boiling Springs, Sc, How To Get Jaeger Level 2, Articles J

jupiter, the bringer of jollity analysis